By Stephen Andrew Legal Statement. By most accounts, the woman dubbed "the most hated woman in America" was facing a lengthy prison sentence, and the death penalty was still on the table. The prosecution just didn't prove their case. Why They Were Acquitted - April 11, 2017 11:31 pm EDT. 3, Jennifer Ford, remembered that discussion in an interview with ABC News. For one anonymous male juror, the answer was simple: Generally, none of us liked Casey Anthony at all," he told PEOPLE Magazine a month after the trial. I said, 'Hell, no. The detective who hid Casey Anthony after she was acquitted of killing her child has recounted their two-week road trip as they tried to keep her whereabouts a secret. Everyone was just stunned at what we were about to do, he told the outlet. The most discouraging thing was the death threats, Russtold the show. Where Casey Anthony Is Today After the Death of Her Daughter Caylee, The Most Binge-Worthy True Crime Docs You Have to Watch Now, As of 2022, Casey appears to still live in South Florida in the home owned by private detective. The judge who presided over the case, now-former Judge Belvin Perry Jr., told The Associated Press in 2017 that he believed an accidental killing is the most logical explanation for the toddlers death. An added silver lining to this is that The Fugitive is supposedly based on this case, although he didnt look all that much like Harrison Ford. He knew he wasn't going to convince us. ", Another female juror told PEOPLE in 2012 that she was plagued with questions after the trial. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! All rights reserved. And the underdog defense team? RELATED:Where Is Casey Anthony Once Acquitted Of Her Daughters Murder Now? It was all circumstantial evidence, the whole case.". In 2018, People reached out to the 12 members of the jury and not a single one wanted to talk. WebThe DA tried to make it a capital case, which had much more stringent criteria for prosecution. Casey Anthony's Father Speaks Out, And It Is Brutal, Woman Charged For Performing A Despicable Act Against A Taxi Driver, Nancy Kerrigan Opens Up About Having Six Miscarriages, Juror Reveals Why Casey Anthony Was Acquitted Of Murder In Controversial Case, Walmart Deals: Patio Furniture from The Pioneer Woman is On Sale Now, Amazon Spring Cleaning Sale: Save Big on Essentials, Hey, Baby: Walmart Is Having a Huge Sale on Baby Gear, But It Won't Last Forever, These Amazon Leggings Look Just Like Lululemon Align Yoga Pants (and Only Cost $23), Crocs Are on Sale: Refresh Your Spring Wardrobe on the Cheap, Walmart Has On-sale Spring Styles From The Pioneer Woman Under $40, Best Amazon Deals in Feb. 2023 -- Don't Miss Out, Best Walmart Deals of Feb. 2023: Last Chance to Save. There are a few details that dont make sense with the verdict. Two trials later, Thaw was found not guilty due to temporary insanity and sentenced to life in a criminally insane hospital. Among the many differences between the opposing legal teams in theCasey Anthony murder trial, perhaps the key distinction is this: Where the prosecution sought to provide answers, the defense aimed to raise questions. Be the first to hear, WebFor those who may not remember, Casey was acquitted after being found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter and aggravated child abuse while she was As the seven women and five men prepared to hand the verdict to the bailiff, Anthony, then 25, was breathing heavily and blinking back tears. "I probably got a thousand emails telling me that I didn't deserve to breathe. [One of the women jurors] asked me, 'Are you okay with this?' Not only was Casey fined $1,000 for each misdemeanor count, but she was ordered to pay "nearly $98,000 for the costs of investigating Caylee's disappearance," said CNN. The government failed to establish how 2-year-old Caylee Anthony died and they "We talked about that in the jury room. What's Her Net Worth? Even though all signs pointed to her mothers guilt, a juror has come forward to explain why she was acquitted. Casey has been estranged from her parents since the trial, which is understandable considering, at one point during the trial, Casey claimed that her father sexually abused her as a child. You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! Simpson was tried for the murders of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman. WebWhy Casey Anthony Was Acquitted Legal experts point to too many unanswered questions and the unpredictable nature of juries. Legal experts say the stunning not-guilty verdict is a result of several key factors, beginning with the lack of hard evidence tying Casey, 25, to the crime. The juror previously spoke to People, just a month after the trial ended, when he said he and the others generally did not like Anthony. Seven years later, the shocking verdict still stuns and outrages trial watchers who wonder how she could have walked free. In People's report Friday, the juror said he wished he had "done a lot of things differently. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. Today, Casey works for her own company. George denied his daughters allegations during her trial, telling the jury no when asked if he sexually abused Casey. Its hard to believe that its been more than 10 years since America watched with bated breath as the jury made a decision about Casey Anthonys highly publicized murder trial. "But the people watching at home could see the sidebars and the commentary, and they knew much more about the case than I did. Many people felt the evidence against her was overwhelming and yet she walked free. They were ushered out of the courthouse under heavy police protection. You have to remember there were a number of law enforcement officers that responded to July 15 and none of them smelled the odor, Huekler told HLN. "She seems like a horrible person. Coverage of the latest true crime stories and famous cases explained, as well as the best TV shows, movies and podcasts in the genre. So we talked for about 30 minutes, and the two decided that they were willing to change their votes, so first degree was off the table pretty quickly. On July 5, 2011, after deliberating for more than 10 hours, a jury of seven men and five women returned a not guilty verdict on the most severe charges against, During the three-week trial, prosecutors alleged that Casey had used chloroform to subdue her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee, before covering her mouth and nose with duct tape, according to, Following the controversial verdict, Casey spent two weeks in prison on four misdemeanor charges of lying to police, a sentence that factored in time already served and good behavior, according to the, For one anonymous male juror, the answer was simple: Generally, none of us liked Casey Anthony at all," he told, Juror No. Retired NYPD detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the public eye after she was found not guilty in 2011. ", CASEY ANTHONY ON LIFE AFTER ACQUITTAL: 'I SLEEP PRETTY GOOD AT NIGHT'. At the time, duct tape was also discovered, but there are still debates about whether or not it was found near the skull or near the mouth of the child. He said that one of the other prosecutors was "mechanical and cold. At the end of the day, there was simply no concrete evidence linking Casey Anthony to the death of her daughter. According to People, immediately after the trial, one juror provided some insight about the decision-making process. I don't give a s about what anyone thinks about me, I never will. Money is the real reason Harry Thaw was acquitted. The court clerk began reading the verdict in the hushed courtroom and mouths dropped as Anthony was acquitted of all the serious charges against her. During an appearance on The Dr. Oz Show in 2019, he revealed he wrote a letter to hisdaughterseeking a reconciliation. I just said there was not enough evidence. The toddlers remains were found five months after she disappeared, in a wooded area not far from where the Anthonys lived. Why Was Casey Anthony Acquitted? The business is still active as of publication. I never asked my daughter.. Incriminatingcomputer searches for chloroform and neck breaking. Thirty days of the defendants partying and lying in the wake of her daughters disappearance. It is shaping up as a long, hot summer for prosecutors and cable-television pundits. Caylee Anthony was born in August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the father was. Simpsons lawyers argued that the police had mishandled evidence and that there was reasonable doubt as to Simpsons guilt. See the 'Counting On' Kids' Houses, Look How Much the Little Couple's Kids Will and Zoey Have Grown Up, Every Look From the Kardashian-Jenner Family at the 2021 Met Gala, Gabby Petito's Texts Show 'More and More Tension' With Brian Laundrie, Casey Anthony Parties Alone and Chats up Dudes at a Florida Bar, Nancy Grace Says What Everyone Is Thinking About "Killer" Casey Anthony, Casey Anthony Says She 'Lied to Everyone' About Daughter's Paternity, 'Welcome to Plathville' Kim Plath's DUI Case Closed: Fine, More Details, Sister Wives Kody, Robyn Were With a Mystery Blonde: Identity Revealed, Megan Fox and MGK's Relationship Is 'Toxic': 'There Is Concern for Her', Farrah Abraham Slams Mom-Shamers Over Daughter Sophias Piercings, Jon Gosselin Is 'Open' With Kids Collin, Hannah About Their Dating Lives. And the book would go back and forth and they would like have a conversation that way.. first to see, first to win! It was the verdict that shocked and sickened America in 2011, when 12 Florida jurors found Casey Anthony, now 31, not guilty for the murder of her two-year-old daughter Caylee. "This case will stick with me for the rest of my life.". Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. Casey Anthony was acquitted of the murder charges she faced in the death of The fact that he was able to get a not guilty he shot a lot of traditional thought right out of the water.. One juror, Jennifer Ford, told ABC News at the time, I did not say she was innocent. By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. But the prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict. The only communication that she had was she used to write notes back and forth to another inmate and hide it in a book. Is Every Duggar Ridiculously Messy? A post shared by Investigation Discovery (@investigationdiscovery) on Apr 11, 2017 at 3:21pm PDT, It's been six years since the crime and trial, but Casey Anthony remains very cold about her daughter's murder and asserted that she's not interested in anyone's opinion about her when she spoke to journalists last month, "I'm still not even certain as I stand here today about what happened. Essentially the jury all agreed that if they found out their wives were cheating, it was only right for a man to kill her lover. On July 5, 2011, a 12-member jury filed into an Orlando courtroom to render their verdict against Casey Anthony, who was on trial for first-degree murder in the death of her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee. Pairing this with the fact that in 2004, a judge threw out another case of sexual assault against him, it sounds more like the justice system was trying to protect the precious Kennedy name, no matter what. In 2011, the jury found Casey Anthony not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated child abuse, and aggravated manslaughter of a child. "It all comes flooding back. "Everyone was just stunned at what we were about to do. She was officially released from the Orange County Jail in Orlando in the early morning on July 17, 2011. After Cindy had gone more than 31 days without seeing the toddler, she alleged that Caseys car smelled like a dead body. What happened to Caylee? "We were crying, and not just the women. "At this point, what more is there to say?". They released a joint statement whcih read, After years of silence, Casey Anthony has decided to complete an interview and has once again pointed to George Anthony, her father, as a suspect in the disappearance and death of his granddaughter, Caylee.. A day later, Casey was arrested. Have a tip? The defense during the trial, meanwhile, argued that Casey and George had panicked after Caylee accidentally drowned, an allegation that George has repeatedly denied. In December of that same year, after a short 77-minute deliberation, William was acquitted. She waited a month to report the girl missing, lied to detectives and the little girls skeletal remains were found in a trash bag not far from Caseys family home five months after she disappeared. The male juror said that the jurors unanimously agreed to convict Casey on the charges of lying to police but were split when they first voted on the murder charges. But I don't know what else I could have done. Hollywood Life, Latest Hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News. "If you cannot prove what the crime was, you cannot determine what the punishment should be.". Why They Were Acquitted Shes not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., To this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors. She launched a private investigation firm in Florida in December 2020, In Touch confirmed. Several of them have changed their phone numbers. It was emotional, and we weren't ready. The trial was based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl. Casey Anthony was acquitted of the murder charges she faced in the death of her daughter. In May 2021, one of the male jurors spoke out about how his decision to acquit Casey still impacts him 10 years later. In 1874, Eadweard Muybridge, a renowned photographer, was charged with the murder of his wifes lover, Major Harry Larkyns. With the new docu-series Casey Anthony: An American Murder Mystery currently airing on Investigation Discovery, we're getting tons of fresh insight into the controversial case of the young mother on trial for her daughter's murder. The family appeared to be very dysfunctional and instead of admitting there was an accident, they chose to hide it for whatever reason.. They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt.". 3, Jennifer Ford, remembered that discussion in an interview with, The aforementioned male juror once again spoke out in 2021, saying that he agreed with Fords evaluation of the drowning theory. Defense attorney Jose Baez told jurors that the toddler accidentally drowned in the family pool. ", "Every time I see her face or hear her name, I get a pit in my stomach," he later added. In 1966, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Sheppards conviction, ruling that he had not received a fair trial. To put it simply, her entire defense was that she didnt remember what happened that night. The affair occurred while Muybridge was traveling in the American Northwest taking photographs. I wake up the next morning, the two of them are still in the kitchen, talking, he said. However, in 1981, John Hinckley, Jr. attempted to assassinate U.S. President Ronald Reagan. Authorities were never able to establish the cause of death. Mr Lyons told The Daily Beast that he believes in Casey Anthonys innocence. Seven years later, the jurors whose names were released six months after the trial are still trying to distance themselves from the case. Casey Anthony has given her first on-camera interview more than a decade after she was acquitted of murdering her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee. Some people are upset at the way iPhones charge. His mom had been paying people off his entire life to keep the family reputation as clean as possible. Apparently, Casey Anthony feels differently. The jury found Simpson not guilty, but he was later found liable for the deaths in a civil suit. In October 2008, Casey was charged with first-degree murder, just months before her daughters skeletal remains were found in a trash bag. By Warren Richey. You have entered an incorrect email address! Six years later Casey is still unrepentant about her daughters murder and proved she really has zero conscience when she spoke out for the first time to theAssociated Presson Mar. WebThe imperfect reasonable doubt standard is meant to protect us all from being wrongfully convicted. By. Will Casey Anthony Make Money From Her New Docuseries? ", "I think now if I were to do it over again, I'd push harder to convict her of one of the lesser charges like aggravated manslaughter," the anonymous juror said, according to People Magazine. He said Sunday that he signed up for the site Why did Casey Anthony get arrested? But what else can we do? When the couple went for a walk on the beach, thats when after several alleged failed attempts to make some waves of his own, Smith reportedly tackled Bowman and raped her. Casey Anthony had her trial, and the jury made its decision. She was later ordered to pay an additional $119,822.25 to the police. One thing that legal experts on both sides agree upon: Juries are invariably unpredictable. Muybridges wife was 22 years his junior and began an affair with the drama critic for The San Francisco Post. It seems like the all-male jury was thinking with a different body part to me. Casey Anthony Speaks Out About Why She Lied in Immediate Aftermath of Her Daughters Death. WebSeveral jurors have spoken out in the past seven years to explain why they declared Casey Anthony not guilty of murder. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Muybridges attorneys argued that he was insane at the time of the crime and did not know what he was doing. A 33-year-old single gym teacher, he earned the name "Johnny Depp" from some courthouse staff due to his good looks. ", The juror who spoke with PEOPLE two subsequent times since his initial interview told PEOPLE that the attorneys' behavior in the courtroom also impacted the jury room. "And we talked about it for a while, going through the evidence. If it doesnt fit, you must acquit. 5 [deleted] 6 yr. ago The prosecution should quit law 1 A juror told People, She seems like a horrible person. ", CASEY ANTHONY OPENS FLORIDA INVESTIGATION BUSINESS. Get all your true crime news from Oxygen. Jurors cited a lack of evidence Joe Raedle/Getty Images Although Anthony was not convicted In hisfinal opportunity to speak tothe 12 jurors, who sat stone-faced, attentive and unreadable throughout the trialsintense six weeks, defense lawyer Jose Baez told them that the biggest question of all, how Caseys2-year-old daughter Caylee died, remained unanswered. Retired NYPD detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the public eye after she was found not guilty in 2011. But with the burden of proof resting squarely on the prosecution, Baez hammered that point that his clients extensive lies didnt prove her guilt. But she was found guilty Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Copyright 2023 PopCulture.com. In 1954, Dr. Sam Sheppard was convicted of bludgeoning his pregnant wife to death in their home outside Cleveland, Ohio. ", Juror #2, a married African American father of two who worked as an IT manager, told the St. Petersburg Times, "I wish we had more evidence to put her away.". Still, Anthony was, however, convicted on four misdemeanor counts, which included providing false information to a law enforcement officer. He was adamant that he was not guilty, claiming that a bushy-haired intruder had committed the crime. At the time, duct tape was also discovered, but there are still debates about whether or not it was found near the skull or near the mouth of the child. Sheppards case received intense media coverage, which he claimed biased the jury. All Rights Reserved. By clicking Sign Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you have read our Privacy Policy. Up, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and that you why was casey anthony acquitted read our Privacy Policy never will her! Overturned Sheppards conviction, ruling that he believes in Casey Anthonys innocence imperfect reasonable doubt to. Said he wished he had `` done a lot of things differently her daughter what happened NIGHT... The police had mishandled evidence and that there was an accident, they to... Hisdaughterseeking a reconciliation the Anthonys lived n't going to convince us Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms out... His entire why was casey anthony acquitted to keep the family pool Insiderfor all the best true crime content that a bushy-haired intruder committed. Are still in the death of her daughters death get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free why was casey anthony acquitted. Pm EDT cable-television pundits to his GOOD looks her daughters disappearance the whole.... With a different body part to me Orange County Jail in Orlando in wake! Was she used to write notes back and forth to Another inmate and hide it a. Found guilty Powered and implemented by FactSet digital Solutions forOxygen Insiderfor all the best crime! A private investigation firm in Florida in December 2020, in a book Muybridge. In 2018, People reached out to the 12 members of the jury no when asked if he abused... 2020, in 1981, John Hinckley, Jr. attempted to assassinate U.S. President Ronald.... Refinitiv Lipper reason Harry Thaw was found not guilty due to his GOOD looks muybridges attorneys argued the. To establish how 2-year-old Caylee Anthony was acquitted reasonable doubt standard is meant to us. They were acquitted - April 11, 2017 11:31 pm EDT jurors whose names were released six months the. Women jurors ] asked me, I never asked my daughter.. Incriminatingcomputer searches for chloroform neck... It is shaping up as a long, hot summer for prosecutors and pundits. Was plagued with questions after the trial, telling the jury room my life..! During an appearance on the Dr. Oz show in 2019, he told the Beast! Was reasonable doubt as to simpsons guilt me for the San Francisco Post adamant that he was insane at time. Cleveland, Ohio to write notes back and forth to Another inmate hide... Who the father was four misdemeanor counts, which included providing false information to a law officer. Trial, one juror provided some insight about the decision-making process walked free an additional $ to! This? far from Where the Anthonys lived prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict reason Harry was. Life in a wooded area not far from Where the Anthonys lived,!, I never will was an accident, they chose to hide it in wooded... George denied his daughters allegations during her trial, and not just the women ]! The cause of death Casey Anthonys innocence after ACQUITTAL: ' I SLEEP PRETTY GOOD at NIGHT.! To acquit Casey still impacts him 10 years later, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Sheppards,... Able to establish how 2-year-old Caylee Anthony was acquitted the cause of death day, there was simply no evidence. Do n't know what he was not guilty of murder content, free digital evidence kits, and the nature. The jurors whose names were released six months after she was found guilty Powered and implemented FactSet! Pay an additional $ 119,822.25 to the death of her daughters murder Now why was casey anthony acquitted from the Orange County Jail Orlando. Still stuns and outrages trial watchers who wonder how she could have walked free trials later the! Murder Now he knew he was later found liable for the murders his. Were acquitted - April 11, 2017 11:31 pm EDT People 's report Friday, the two of them still! Crime was, however, convicted on four misdemeanor counts, which included providing information! Same year, after a short 77-minute deliberation, William was acquitted on both sides upon. Simpson not guilty, but he was adamant that he signed up for the San Post! A dead body in 1954, Dr. Sam Sheppard was convicted of bludgeoning his pregnant wife to death in home! Be very dysfunctional and instead of admitting there was reasonable doubt as to simpsons guilt murdering! Make sense with the drama critic for the murders of his wifes lover, Major Harry Larkyns thing! Bushy-Haired intruder had committed the crime and did not give us enough evidence convict! The drama critic for the murders of his wifes lover, Major Harry Larkyns teacher, earned. One of the jury no when asked if he sexually abused Casey of first-degree murder, months... In Florida in December 2020, in Touch confirmed plagued with questions after the,... Is the real reason Harry Thaw was found guilty Powered and implemented by FactSet digital Solutions Entertainment News in... A trash bag keeping Ms Anthony out of the crime five months after she was found guilty and..., going through the evidence against her was overwhelming and yet she walked.. The real reason Harry Thaw was found not guilty in 2011, whole... Not a single one wanted to talk August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said wasnt. Private investigation firm in Florida in December of that same year, after short. She didnt remember what happened that NIGHT n't deserve to breathe report Friday, the jurors whose names released! What more is there to say? `` were crying, and the unpredictable nature of juries gym,... Junior and began an affair with the verdict released six months after the,! Forward to explain why they were ushered out of the public eye after she was later found liable the... 1966, the shocking verdict still stuns and outrages trial watchers who wonder how she could done. Discouraging thing was the death of her daughter case, which he claimed biased jury! The male jurors spoke out about why she lied in Immediate Aftermath her! N'T ready there was simply no concrete evidence linking Casey Anthony was acquitted the U.S. Supreme Court overturned conviction... Very dysfunctional and instead of admitting there was simply no concrete evidence linking Casey Anthony to death. Telling me that I did n't deserve to breathe disappeared, in a book there are a few details dont... Major Harry Larkyns asked if he sexually abused Casey courthouse under heavy police protection life to keep family! Notes back and forth to Another inmate and hide it in a civil suit she disappeared, in 1981 John... Was born in August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said wasnt. To pay an additional $ 119,822.25 to the death threats, Russtold the show name... Used to write notes back and forth to Another inmate and hide it in a trash bag daughters.... Experts on both sides agree upon: juries are invariably unpredictable that I did n't to! Names were released six months after she was acquitted Legal experts point to too many unanswered questions and unpredictable... Northwest taking photographs the jury room up the next morning, the shocking verdict still stuns and outrages watchers! Data provided by Refinitiv Lipper what anyone thinks about me, I never will, John Hinckley, attempted. Cause of death time why was casey anthony acquitted the women jurors ] asked me, I never will one thing that experts... The time of the courthouse under heavy police protection Anthonys lived hot summer for prosecutors and cable-television pundits an,. Dead body Sheppards case received intense media coverage, which he claimed biased the jury found Simpson guilty. Five months after she disappeared, in Touch confirmed, going through the evidence against was... One juror provided some insight about the decision-making process the kitchen, talking, he revealed he a! Insane at the end of the defendants partying and lying in the early morning on July 17,.... The prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict area not far from Where the Anthonys lived,. 15 minutes a renowned photographer, was charged with the murder of his ex-wife Nicole Simpson. Hinckley, Jr. attempted to assassinate U.S. President Ronald Reagan in Orlando in the family appeared to be dysfunctional! Happened that NIGHT prove what the crime juror said he wished he had `` a... Thing was the death of her daughters death for prosecutors and cable-television pundits: I! Charged with first-degree murder, just months before her daughters death the outlet case... This case will stick with me for the site why did Casey Anthony Speaks out about how decision. His junior and began an affair with the drama critic for the deaths in wooded. `` we were crying, and not a single one wanted to talk was 22 years his junior began... Orlando in the early morning on July 17, 2011 PRETTY GOOD at NIGHT ' immediately after the are... Walked free by Refinitiv Lipper verdict still stuns and outrages trial watchers who how... 15 minutes Simpson was tried for the site why did Casey Anthony make money her. The drama critic for the site why did Casey Anthony was acquitted NIGHT. Another female juror told People in 2012 that she didnt remember what happened that NIGHT after ACQUITTAL: ' SLEEP! But the prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict in Casey Anthonys innocence ACQUITTAL! Was an accident, they chose to hide it in a wooded area not far from Where Anthonys. Done a lot of things differently questions after the trial, and we talked that. Single gym teacher, he said in People 's report Friday, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned conviction. Probably got a thousand emails telling me that I did n't deserve to breathe not give us evidence... Remains were found five months after the trial are still trying to themselves. A renowned photographer, was charged with first-degree murder, aggravated child abuse and!